New Thumbnail for "Happy Birthday Baby."

I have been reading articles about how to make your video more appealing. One thing that everyone says is how important your thumbnail is. With that in mind I have spent the afternoon creating a new thumbnail which I feel sure will catch people's attention.  

First I chose selections from each costumed video. Then I edited out the green screen in Photoshop. Once I had png formatted photos with no background, I brought up the background used for the video and placed each costumed Carol. 

The new thumbnail takes its bow here at Best Musical on Broadway today.  https://youtu.be/dtI0lj1JCT0